A deceived reindeer in a local Target parking lot was completely duped by a family’s well-decorated Hyundai Sonata, making love to it for several seconds before realizing it was not another reindeer.

The Johanson family decorates its car with antlers and a red nose every single Christmas, but this is the first time it’s completely tricked a real reindeer.

“I was stunned when we walked out of Target,” father Tim Johanson said. “At first though I couldn’t even tell which was the car and which was the reindeer. We decorated the car too well.”

Several other unconfirmed reports have come in in recent days that reindeer have been equally bamboozled by plastic lawn decorations.